Every morning at 57 North Broadway, Katrina Poulin runs whole grain through a stone mill and then bakes with the flour. The kitchen writes that day's menu from what the farms delivered. By 8 a.m. the shelves next to the dining room are stocked with Hudson Valley greens, pasture-raised meat, dairy and bags of the same fresh-milled flour.
The shop is called Tarrytown Local, and it opened in October. The timing matters to anyone in Sleepy Hollow Manor whose Saturday starts at the farmers market. The TaSH Farmers Market's posted 2026 outdoor season at Patriots Park ends November 21. Its weekly winter season doesn't start until January 9. In between, a store a short walk north of Main Street on Route 9 sells that kind of food Wednesday through Sunday, and one of the farms in its directory is also on TaSH's winter list.
A grocery whose kitchen cooks from its own shelves
Tarrytown Local is three businesses in one storefront: a small grocery, a breakfast-and-lunch restaurant and a bakery. The grocery is open Wednesday through Sunday from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m. The dining room serves Wednesday through Sunday from 9 a.m. to 3 p.m. Both are closed Monday and Tuesday.
There is no fixed menu. The kitchen writes a new one each morning around the farm deliveries and posts it on the store's website. One recent day, as reported by Hudson Valley Wave, the menu included a roasted cauliflower soup with brown butter and pepitas, a breakfast sandwich on house buns with Titusville eggs and 5 Spoke cheddar, and a smashburger made with Harlem Valley Homestead beef. Most dishes on that menu were $15 to $20. Walk-ins are welcome, and tables can be booked online through SevenRooms. Dinner service is planned but hasn't started yet. The team has said wine dinners and tasting menus are coming.
Chef and culinary director Fox Schanzer explained the three-part setup to Westchester Magazine. He and owner Steve Wazny first planned a locally sourced deli, then found that the space they were looking at was too large for one. "From there, we realized how synergistic a grocery/restaurant/bakery could be and really loved the ability to showcase all of the ingredients we sell in the grocery on our menu, and vice versa," Schanzer told the magazine.
In practice, you can eat a bowl of soup at a table and buy the greens, bread and flour that went into it on the way out. Farmers markets offer the same thing on Saturday mornings. Tarrytown Local offers it five days a week, until 8 p.m.
Bread that starts as whole grain on a stone mill
The bakery is what sets the store apart. Every loaf and pastry uses flour milled in the shop shortly before baking, with the bran and germ left in. The grain comes from four growers: Seneca Grain and Bean in Penn Yan, Hudson Valley Hops and Grains in Ancram, Great Joy Family Farm in Pine Bush and Small Valley Milling in Halifax, Pennsylvania. Varieties in rotation include Renan and Redeemer hard red wheat, Frederick soft white wheat, a landrace rye, several spelts, Gehl oats and black rice.
The bread is naturally leavened. Hudson Valley Wave's list includes a sourdough batard, a deli rye made with sorghum syrup and caraway, and a sourdough focaccia. Pastries rotate and have included a glazed donut, a savory scone, spelt cacao biscotti and a black rice cookie. Because the flour is whole grain and freshly milled, the selection changes with each harvest. The grocery sells the flour by the bag, and staff will mill a specific grain to order. For anyone baking in December, that is a short drive down Route 9 instead of a mail order.
The address also has a bakery history. Tarrytown's Planning Board minutes from March 2026 list the previous tenant at 57 North Broadway as Pastry Chef, a bakery with retail space, seating up front and a commercial kitchen in the back.
Whose farms are on the shelf
The store's farm directory names its producers and where they farm:
- 5 Spoke Creamery, Goshen
- Deep Roots Farm, Copake
- Harlem Valley Homestead, Wingdale
- Seneca Grain and Bean, Penn Yan
- Titusville Farm, Poughkeepsie
Sourcing starts with Hudson Valley farms, moves to other New York producers next, and goes to domestic suppliers only when nothing closer fits. Coffee and certain spices are among the few items that come from farther away. Schanzer told Westchester Magazine that nearly everything is bought directly from the producers, "down to the salt and oil."
Wazny laid out his reasons on the store's blog, Good Dirt, in a post written while the shop was being built. He wanted to sell reliable, affordable, healthy food and to support the people who grow and make it. Before opening the store, he left a career in corporate litigation to work as a line cook in New York City. His team includes Poulin as miller and baker, Rick Krebs as sous chef, Maddy Gentile as general manager and Jill Santopietro running the grocery.
The weeks between the last outdoor market and January 9
The owners chose Tarrytown partly because of the farmers market. "We are right down the street from one of the best farmers' markets in the state (The TaSH), and folks around here know good, local food," Schanzer told Westchester Magazine. That market runs on a seasonal calendar, while the store's posted hours run five days a week.
TaSH's posted outdoor season, on Saturdays from 8:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. at Patriots Park, runs May 23 through November 21. The market's vendor map lists one more date on December 5. TaSH's listing on its vendor platform, Marketspread, gives that day as an afternoon market, 2 to 6 p.m. at Patriots Park, with 69 vendor entries. After that, the vendor map lists no more dates until January.
Stone Barns Center for Food and Agriculture, at 630 Bedford Road in Tarrytown, fills part of that gap. Its market calendar lists a Thanksgiving Market on November 22 and a Holiday Market on Sunday, December 13, both from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m., with farm produce, meat, eggs, cut flowers and local vendors. Outside those dates, the campus is open Wednesday through Sunday from 9:30 a.m. to 3 p.m., and visitors can shop the Market without a reservation. Our weekend guide to Pocantico Hills and Stone Barns covers the rest of the drive.
If you'd rather keep a Saturday farmers market through the cold months, two nearby villages hold one. Pleasantville's market runs outdoors all year, and from January through March it meets Saturdays from 9:30 a.m. to noon at 10 Memorial Plaza, the Metro-North parking lot. The Hastings Farmers Market runs December through May, Saturdays from 9:30 a.m. to 1 p.m., in the commuter lot at 131 Southside, across from the Hastings-on-Hudson station.
For a household in Sleepy Hollow Manor, the closest option between markets is the shop on North Broadway. Its grocery is open until 8 p.m. five days a week, so a weeknight stop on the way home from the Tarrytown station works.
When TaSH returns, one farm sells in both places
TaSH's vendor map lists 16 Saturdays of winter market, January 9 through April 24, 2027. The Marketspread listing for January 9 gives hours of 9 a.m. to 12:30 p.m., shorter than the summer schedule. Since the winter location can change, check the TaSH site before the first Saturday.
The early winter rosters include familiar names. Mead Orchards, Thousand Leaf Gardens, Wave Hill Breads and JD Family Farm are listed for January 9. Chaseholm Farm Creamery, Fly Honey Farms, Hudson Valley Breads and Deep Roots Farm are listed for January 16.
Deep Roots Farm of Copake is also in Tarrytown Local's farm directory. So the same farm supplies the store on North Broadway and appears on the TaSH winter market's January roster. Shoppers who come to the winter market for Hudson Valley Breads or Wave Hill Breads now have a third local bakery to compare, one that mills its flour in the same building where it bakes.
Tarrytown Local posts each day's menu at tarrytownlocal.com and posts updates on Instagram at @tarrytown_local. The store also caters, from a few dozen breakfast sandwiches up to a multicourse dinner, which may help anyone hosting in December.
At Aloia Stroub Team, we track the new everyday stops around Sleepy Hollow Manor, from a stone mill on Route 9 to the winter market's return. If you're curious how the village's growing list of everyday stops figures into what your home is worth, request a free home valuation and we'll walk you through it.